Gain vs Wave Angle

Something I've noticed is that most don't consider is the whole picture when it comes to antenna gain. Often only peak gain at the wave angle it occurs at is quoted. Sometimes a pattern is shown with no gain figures which is useless, this is often the case with verticals.

To build a picture of what one might expect when considering low band DX antennas, I feel it's better to consider the gain at different wave angles.

To illustrate this, I created a table in a spreadsheet with several different antennas and the gain they have at different angles. LiberOffice Calc has the option to fill cell background color based on the value. The table is sorted based on the gain at 5 degrees.



I used MMANA-GAL for the modeling of these antennas. Most are 40m antennas, those that can be matched on 80m are also shown.

Wire antenna heights are 40ft/12m, the inverted Vs are 15m/50ft, the delta loops have a minimum height of 1m/3ft.

Nov 15 2019:
Looking at the models of OCFDs again - I realized due to the lobe formation being either side of the X or Y axis on 40m and above, the far field plot does not show the peak gain as its simply sliced down the X axis. The geometry would need to be offset such that one of the main lobes aligns with the X axis. Comparing the elevation and gain results on the calculation tab with a plain 40m dipole vs an 80m OCFD on 40m band, the OCFD has around 1 dBi more gain at the same elevation angle (52 degrees when 12m above ground), which comes from the two broadside nulls that form. Under far field plots, the far field elevation angle can be changed, comparing gain at 40, 30, 20 and 10 degrees shows the OCFD having about 1 dBi more than a dipole at the same height.

I'll need to update my table..

ZS6BKW Antenna

What else is there that's under 100 ft, at a minimum covers 40 and 20m with out the need for an ATU, and will work on 75m?

After considering a few ideas, I took a closer look at the ZS6BKW antenna which is an optimized variant of the well known G5RV. This antenna checks the boxes on these points:

• Light weight - no traps, coax etc hanging.
• Low SWR on 40 and 20m, can run ~1kW with the AL-80B.
• Respectable gain on 20m if you have the luck or luxury of orientating the broadside to favor somewhere of interest.
• Will work on 75m with the remote ATU I already have. It's essentially a 1/3 wave dipole, as such has reduced efficiency since the resistive component falls rapidly when a dipole is under 3/8 wave length.
• Also covers 17, 12, part 10 and 6m with low SWR.

Spent a couple weeks reading everything I could find, and playing with models - one is included with MMANA-GAL, others can be found online.

Decided it was worth trying out. Initially I was going to order the parts from The Wireman and build it my self, but found a source of these pre-made cheaper and better built for $60 (normally $90) plus shipping from Amateur Radio Supplies => ZS6BKW G5RV 80, so went that route. 

Current setup:

• Antenna apex at 50ft, ends in inverted V configuration.
• K9YC inspired choke balun - 7 turns of RG-8X through two mix 31 clamp on ferrites.
• Remote ATU between the choke and coax to the shack. 

How does it work?

• Except for 15m, low SWR on six bands from 40 to 12m, parts of 10 and 6m.
• Remote ATU dials it in on 75, 60, and 15m, brings the total to nine bands.
• 30m is the odd one out, ATU fails to find a match in my case.
• Performance on 75m wasn't great on transmit, but it's better than nothing. My OCFD is notably better on 75m being a full 1/2 wave on this band. This may be why the G5RV is popular, at 10ft longer than the ZS6BKW that might make enough difference on 75m for it to be "good enough".

Nine bands where only three need an ATU, with 93 feet of wire in the air is OK by me. 30m might be an issue for some, but you can't always win 'em all :-) 

Links to further information:

• G5RV Facts - W8JI.
• The G5RV Antenna System Re-Visited Part 3: The Almost-No-ATU ZS6BKW - Cebik.
• Analysis of the G5RV by G3TXQ.
• ZS6BKW Modifications (web.archive.org), more bands with out an ATU - W5DXP.
• ZS6BKW vs G5RV - (web.archive.org) AARA Presentation, includes charts, plots, and MMANA-GAL files.
• ZS6BKW construction details - VK2ACD.
• How to build a ZS6BKW Antenna - VK2KMI. 
• eHam Reviews of the W8AMZ commercial ZS6BKW antenna - looks to be identical in construction to the one I got from Amateur Radio Supplies linked above.
• The ZS6BKW antenna from the horse's mouth - Brian Austin G0GSF (ex ZS6BKW).